Entries in America (2)

Monday
May172010

Is the American Political System Broken?

Have you ever thought about how broken the American political system is? I know it sounds pessimistic, but think about it. There are two major problems:

1) There are so many major issues that should be addressed but never will because of the discourse of American politics. Some recent examples I can think of are net neutrality and the ACTA treaty. If you're not sure what they are about, go ahead and give it a good google. 

The landscape of American politics is all run on either fear or pandering. The issues that take hold are important because they have to deal with your "safety" and must be discussed immediately. It's either that or politicians spend so much time telling the American people how smart we are and trying to win voters over that way.

But really... are we really that smart? To be honest, I want my politician to be smarter than I am. The people who are in charge of making policy should be knowledge about the issues at hand. But instead of getting people who are smarter than us, we get people who just know how to make the American people "feel good."

When you hear about issues that you feel like are important, you almost begin to give up. Who's going to listen to you? You can get people to care, but unless you can make it a mainstream issue, nothing is going to happen. It's enough to make you give up on democracy. And speaking of...

2) The reason that a lot of these issues don't gain steam is because most people don't give a damn. When you think about how many important topics need to be tackled, most people don't want to participate. The only way for people to participate in the "civic discourse" is to vote. But what about talking about these problems? What about getting people to think about these things? Getting them to vote for you does not mean that you are going to help people to critically think through these different things. In fact, what ends up happening is if someone does vote, it is usually uneducated and based on social pressures.

What we need are people who walk through these issues with the average American (whatever that looks like). We need political ambassadors, those who are going to engage people in critical conversation so that they can figure out what they think and believe about how the country should be run. Unfortunately, the only thing we get now is political propaganda. There really is no "neutral" source.
While it's easy to feel defeated and give up on the political system, it's still an important thing. It may be broken, but we still need to take responsibility for the decisions that are made about the way we can live our lives.

But what do you think? Is there a way to fix the political system? How can we engage people in critical dialogue without brainwashing them? Is it not as hopeless as it seems?
Wednesday
Nov112009

Republicans Are the Most American

You may be surprised to hear me say such a thing, but this post is most likely not what you're expecting. Republicans have often touted as part of their logic that they are the most patriotic, that they uphold American values the best. And to that I say, they're right.

When we think about American values, we think of a highly individualized culture. You should be able to do whatever you want with your money, what's most important is that you feel good about things. But why do we attach ourselves to such values so readily? If we were to examine other cultures, we would find a much more collective feel to the people. While the individual is important, it is not so important that it forgets about the greater good of the whole.

Let's take a practical example in the news, Universal Health Care (UHC). One proposed idea for UHC is to raise taxes on people but provide health care for everyone in the United States. Immediately the individualistic part of ourselves cry out. We say, "No one should be able to tell me how I can spend my money." It's an interesting argument when you think about it, because you would be spending that same money on health care anyway. The only difference is that you are choosing to spend that money instead of it being spent for you.

Now individual choice and freedom is an important thing. Without individual choice and freedom, we become mindless drones. There is always room for critical thinking. But there is something interesting happening in the collective conscious of the people where perhaps focusing on individual values alone isn't going to cut it. Perhaps there are more noble goals to live for. As the world becomes a smaller place, it becomes harder to ignore the needs of the ones around us.

So I'll make the claim again: Republicans are more American than any other political party. But here's the question. Are those American values really what we should be holding to? It is immediately at this point when someone makes a comment like this that they are branded an anarchist or wanting to take down America. I don't want any part of that. But I have to ask, what are those values?

Freedom? What exactly does freedom mean? Does freedom mean wanting to have a free market economy, but not the freedom to allow people to make their own moral choices about abortion? What about liberty? Is there more than one specific way to choose to display one's patriotism for their country? Is it possible to be pro-America without abusing hegemonic power?

These are but a few critical questions about American values. I do think as a people, we need to do some serious examination about what exactly American values are and if we want them to be the things that we hold as our paradigm. When doing so, we may find that there are other values that are more important that the ones we've been told are true and good.