Why I'm Glad Lost Didn't Win Best Drama
Monday, August 30, 2010 at 12:00 PM Congrats to Mad Men for yet another win for Best Drama Series.
Others on the interwebs however are not as... congratulatory.
I read an article on Wired last night entitled "Emmy Night Marks Last Hurrah for Lost." As you can guess from the title of the article, you can figure out who they wanted to win Best Drama. But the argument for Lost to win Best Drama is one that is interesting to me. It goes: Lost should win Best Drama not just because it was great, but also because it would be a hallmark for the sci-fi genre as a whole.
Let's be honest. This is a silly argument. It's like brining affirmative action to the Emmy's. A show shouldn't win just because it is a token show; a show should win because it is truly the best show. Take a look at this list of nominees and tell me that Lost truly deserves it:
- Lost
- Mad Men
- Breaking Bad
- Dexter
- True Blood
- The Good Wife
I can't say anything about True Blood or The Good Wife, but Mad Men, Breaking Bad, and Dexter are just more engaging dramas. Let's think about season 6 of Lost. What happened? What was the drama? Half the season was spent describing a heaven like afterlife where everyone gets to live happily ever after. Most of the conflict that arose on season 6 was forced.
But take a look at these other shows. The narrative is compelling and driven by interesting characters. Lost has interesting characters, but they were never really utilized to tell a good story this season (except for "Ab Eterno"). Wired goes as far as calling Mad Men glacier-paced. Really? Just because the show doesn't involve time travel or smoke monsters doesn't mean it isn't exciting. Try watching the season finale from season 3 and tell me the show is glacier-paced. More drama happens in that episode then all of season 6 of Lost combined.
I'm happy about the outcome and would have honestly been disappointed if Lost won for best drama as a goodbye consolation prize. And it's not like it's all terrible. Lost already won Best Drama once when they truly deserved it: season one.
Best Drama,
Breaking Bad,
Dexter,
Emmys,
Lost,
Mad Men,
The Good Wife,
True Blood,
Wired,
nominations in
TV Shows 




